This or That

[Death]

Ruby (Katie) or Ruby (Gen)

 

[Shurley]

The original, blonde, version, for sure!

War, Famine or Pestilence?

 

[Joan the Vampire Slayer]

War!

Sam or Dean?

 

[Death]

Dean

Donna or Jody?

 

[Shurley]

Depends on my mood, today it's Donna

Madison (Heart) or Sarah (Provenance)?

 

[Death]

I liked them both but Sarah

Garth or Rufus?

 

[Shurley]

Rufus.

Michael!Meatsuit: Young!John or Adam?

 

[Death]

Young John

SoullessSam or Demon Dean?

 

[Shurley]

Toughie! Soulless!Sam was sooo well-played by Jared but went on for too long. Demon!Dean didn't last long enough and wasn't sinister enough, but was awesome to finally get after all that time (plus MOC is my favorite season-arc on the show). So, basically...I don't know...

Lucifer or Crowley?

 

[Death]

Lucifer

Abaddon or Azazel?

 

[Shurley]

Azazel

Ramiel or Asmodeus?

 

[Death]

Asmodeus

Kevin or Donatello?

 

[Shurley]

Kevin

Winchester: John or Mary (adult versions)?

 

[SwanSong]

Mary

Guns or angel blades?

 

[Death]

Guns, the boys silver and white ones are still my favourite

Better in a white suit Sam!Lucifer or Asmodeus?

 

[SwanSong]

Sam!Lucifer FOR SURE

Cas or Jimmy?

 

[Shurley]

Cass

Claire or Alex?

 

[Death]

Claire

Missouri or Pamela?

 

[Shurley]

Missouri

Hannah or Anael (Sister Jo)?

 

[Death]

Hannah

Uriel or Metatron?