This or That

[Shurley]

Boot beer (first scene that comes to mind is in S3 when Dean teaches Sam how to fix the Impala once he's gone)

Goodbye
Sam & Dean in the cemetery in S11 finale or Sam & Dean in the house in the S3 finale?

 

[SwanSong]

Season 3 bawl

The way Dean looks at Pie, or the way Dean looks at Burgers?

 

[Death]

Pie

The French Mistake or Fan Fiction?

 

[SwanSong]

Ohh love them both! The french mistake

Plaid or leather?

 

[Shurley]

Plaid, though it wasn't an easy choice

Castiel's Pimp-mobile or John's black truck?

 

[SwanSong]

The truck

Heaven or Hell?

 

[Death]

Hell - the scene at the end of season 3 with Dean

Purgatory or The Bad Place?

 

[SwanSong]

Purgatory cos I am not sure which bad place you are referencing. And I remember it had lots of forest

The motel minor gods or Chuck!God

 

[Death]

Chuck, I liked the scene in the bunker talking with Lucifer

Bobby's panic room or The Bunker's basement room?

 

[Shurley]

Bobby's panic room -

Spoiler: Reason

Castiel's angel buddy: Balthazar or Hannah?

 

[Death]

Balthazar - I hated Titanic too!

Lenore or Benny?

 

[Shurley]

Benny <3

Buffyverse alum: Amy Acker or Julie Benz?

 

[Death]

Julie Benz - I love that ep

Gabriel or Balthazar?

 

[Shurley]

Gabe!!!

Dean and Lisa or Sam and Amelia?

 

[Death]

Dean and Lisa maybe

Sam and Sarah or Sam and Madison?

 

[Shurley]

Hmm, that's actually a difficult one, but I think I'll go with Sam and Madison.

The French Mistake or Fan Fiction?

 

[Death]

The French Mistake

The Mystery Spot or Changing Channels?

 

[Shurley]

Changing Channels

Jack or Lucifer?

 

[Death]

Lucifer

Nick or Mary?

 

[Joan the Vampire Slayer]

NICK!

Season 1 or 5?