The Actor Game

[Shurley]

Supernatural has a habit of hiring the same actors for different parts, usually due to them filming in a smaller city than Los Angeles. I thought we could make a game out of seeing how many of the different roles we can find. I'll start with what, in my mind, is one of the easiest.

Erica Carroll

1st Appearance - Nurse in Faith

2nd Appearance - Mother in Something Wicked

3rd Appearance - Hannah the Angel

 

[Death]

Ty Olsson

Eli in Bloodlust, Season 2

Benny in Season 8

 

[Shurley]

Aleks Paunovic

1st Appearance - Sean's Friend in Crossroad Blues

2nd Appearance - Skinwalker #2 in All Dogs Go to Heaven

3rd Appearance - Gunner Lawless in Beyond the Mat

 

[Death]

Alexia Fast

Missy - The Benders

Emma - The Slice Girls